Head-to-head for women
Eden vs NewSelf
Eden and NewSelf both offer GLP-1 telehealth to women, but they make different trade-offs on PCOS and hormonal suitability, clinical oversight, price and access. Here they are side-by-side on the Luna Fit Score — our women's-health rubric.
Eden
Higher scoreRanked #9 for women · Grade A−
Luna Fit
Best for: Women who value knowing exactly who is prescribing and where the medication comes from, and will pay above the cheapest tiers for that transparency.
Visit EdenNewSelf
Ranked #54 for women · Grade C
Luna Fit
Best for: Women who are certain they want three months of a flat-priced compounded GLP-1 and will not need to change their mind, because changing it is expensive here.
Visit NewSelfThe verdict for women
Eden edges out NewSelf on the Luna Fit Score, 90 to 64 (A− vs C). Women who value knowing exactly who is prescribing and where the medication comes from, and will pay above the cheapest tiers for that transparency. The reasoning behind that number is in our Eden write-up for women.
NewSelf is still a genuine option — one price at any dose, three months of medication shipped up front — and a set of exit terms and unresolved compliance problems that make it the hardest program on this board to leave. Weigh the six women's-health factors below against your own priorities; our NewSelf write-up for women goes through each of them, and if neither of these two is the one, our ranked shortlist of NewSelf alternatives widens the field.
Side-by-side on the six factors
Both providers scored on the same women's-health rubric — the higher side on each factor is marked. See the methodology.
Price, access & features
| Detail | Eden | NewSelf |
|---|---|---|
| Luna Fit Score | 90/100 · A− | 64/100 · C |
| Overall rank | #9 | #54 |
| Semaglutide | $239/mo | $134.99/mo flat at every dose (as low as $99.97; 3-month term required) |
| Tirzepatide | $349/mo | $224.99/mo flat at every dose (as low as $144.49; 3-month term required) |
| Coverage | All 50 states | 48 states and Puerto Rico (not Mississippi or Louisiana) |
| Brand-name access | Compounded only | Compounded only |
| Oral / sublingual | Injection only | Injection only |
Luna Fit
Eden
Ranked #9 · Grade A−
What we like
- Clear clinician and supply-chain disclosure — among the most transparent on the board about who and what is behind the prescription
- Nationwide availability with both molecules
- High verification confidence: the facts it publishes hold up when checked
The caveats
- Premium pricing versus the cheapest tiers
- Compounded only — no brand-name access
- Not a hormone-specialty clinic; PCOS framing is general
Luna Fit
NewSelf
Ranked #54 · Grade C
What we like
- One flat price at every dose for both molecules, with the dose ladder published beside it
- Three months of medication shipped up front, so there is no waiting on refills mid-titration
- LegitScript certified with a published, checkable ID
The caveats
- FDA warning letter MARCS-CMS 721472, dated 20 February 2026, to NewSelf Limited dba NewSelf, over product labelling and marketing language. As of 1 August 2026 the wording the FDA objected to was still live on the site — five months on, unremediated
- The product pages carry a badge reading 'cancel anytime', while the refund policy requires a three-month commitment and charges a full retail month as an early-cancellation fee. Those cannot both be true
- No refunds: cancelling before the doctor's review costs a $99 administrative fee, and after it nothing is refundable regardless of shipment status
Assume any provider we list may compensate us — we may earn a commission, at no cost to you. Pricing, states and verification reflect each provider's public disclosures at last review; the Luna Fit Score is our editorial judgment per the methodology. Prices change — confirm on each provider's site. Not medical advice; see our disclosure.
More head-to-heads
Neither Eden nor NewSelf is only worth comparing with the other. Eden is also written up against Ondra Health, 2 points apart on the Luna Fit Score — see the Eden–Ondra Health head-to-head. NewSelf is also written up against CoreAge Rx, 29 points apart — see the NewSelf–CoreAge Rx head-to-head.
- Eden vs CoreAge Rx
- Eden vs Enhance MD
- Eden vs yourEra
- NewSelf vs Sesame Care
- NewSelf vs HealthRX
- NewSelf vs Strut Health
Or browse the full comparison hub.